Article Types

PhD Seminar · Chemical Engineering

Choosing a manuscript format from its contribution

Today’s decisions

01

Identify the main contribution of a manuscript.

02

Explain why a particular article type fits that contribution.

03

Check the intended journal’s definition and requirements.

Five article types, battery paper examples and practice choosing a format.

Article formats and the reader’s question

Format Reader’s central question
Research article What new finding does the evidence support?
Review What does the body of literature establish?
Communication / Letter What focused contribution does this journal accept?
Perspective What interpretation or direction deserves attention?
Data paper Can I understand, assess and reuse these data?

Labels and requirements vary by journal. Length alone does not determine the format.

Research article: estimating battery capacity

Zhu et al. Figure 4c: XGBoost estimated versus measured normalized capacity for test cells, with density scale and error histogram.

Contribution: a method for estimating battery capacity.

The graph evaluates estimates against measurements.

Format: research article, supported by new evidence.

Zhu et al. (2022), Fig. 4c. Panel extracted; original labels retained. CC BY 4.0 · Open figure

Review: a synthesis of fast-charging research

Tomaszewska et al. Figure 8 panels a and c: schematic current and voltage profiles for CC-CV and multistage CC-CV charging; original legend retained.

Contribution: a synthesis of fast-charging research.

The schematics organize charging approaches.

Format: review, with a defined literature scope.

Tomaszewska et al. (2019), Fig. 8a,c. Schematic panels rearranged; original legend retained. CC BY 4.0 · Open figure

Communication: a focused electrode study

01

Nie et al. (2021): the publisher labels this a Communication.

02

Contribution: a focused study of transport in thick electrodes.

03

The journal defines the format and required evidence.

Full title and access links appear in the reading guide.

Perspective: a framework for degradation

Magnified detail of the outcome region of Edge et al. Figure 9: lithium inventory loss, stoichiometric drift, impedance change, power fade and capacity fade. Upstream pathways are outside the crop.

Contribution: an organizing view of degradation.

The map connects ideas discussed in the literature.

Publisher category: Perspective.

Edge et al. (2021), Fig. 9 detail. Enlarged outcome region; upstream pathways omitted. CC BY 3.0 · Open figure

Open complete original map

Data Descriptor: a reusable battery aging dataset

Stroebl et al. Figure 8 panels b and d: stage 1 cycle-aging capacity in Ah and DC internal resistance in ohms versus fully equivalent cycles. Original shared temperature legend retained.

Contribution: a documented dataset for reuse.

The curves help readers assess the resource.

Stroebl et al. (2024), Fig. 8b,d. Stage 1 panels rearranged; shared legend retained. CC BY 4.0 · Open figure

Research article and data paper

Decision Research article Data paper
Main contribution A new finding or method A reusable dataset
Role of a figure Evidence for the claim Description or validation of the resource
Main reader task Assess the finding Assess and reuse the data

Both can contain original measurements and share data.

Review and Perspective

Decision Review Perspective
Main contribution Synthesis of existing studies An interpretation, position or direction
Organizing question What does the literature establish? How should we understand or develop the field?
Evidence needed Defined scope and critical comparison A supported argument and its limits

Both use literature. The central purpose and journal definition guide the choice.

Research proposal: a boundary case

01

A proposal explains work that the author plans to do.

02

A research article reports findings supported by completed work.

03

An untested idea needs a plan before it can support a result claim.

A proposal may serve a supervisor, committee or funder. It is not automatically a journal article category.

Worksheet 3A: a defensible article format

8minutes
01

Pairs or groups of three: discuss the four situations.

02

For each, state the format and contribution-based reason.

03

Name one missing requirement or plausible alternative.

Worksheet 3A: reasoning behind the answers

Case Likely format Reason
A: reusable cycling data Data paper Reuse is the main contribution
B: conflicting studies Review Synthesis explains disagreement
C: untested idea Research proposal The evidence is still planned
D: focused supported result Communication / Article New evidence, with journal fit to check

A defensible alternative needs a clear change in purpose, evidence or journal fit.

Worksheet 3B: choosing your manuscript format

6minutes
01

Write the contribution and intended reader in one sentence.

02

Choose a format and justify it using the evidence you have.

03

Ask a partner to challenge the choice. Record one next check.

The target journal’s requirements

01

Confirm that the journal accepts the proposed article type.

02

Read its definition, audience and scope.

03

Check structure, limits, evidence and data requirements.

Save or download your worksheet. Browser drafts are not submitted.

Exit ticket & anonymous feedback

3 minutes

01

One format-selection concept check.

02

Your project: format, audience and missing evidence.

03

One point still unclear, then anonymous feedback.

QR code for session 3 exit ticket and anonymous feedback

Exit ticket: optional student ID. Feedback: no name or student ID.

Battery papers and reading guide

01

Research article: Zhu et al. (2022); further reading: Severson et al. (2019).

02

Review: Tomaszewska et al. (2019).

03

Communication: Nie et al. (2021).

04

Perspective: Edge et al. (2021).

05

Data Descriptor: Stroebl et al. (2024).

Full citations, publisher labels and reading prompts are available through the link.